https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/2287/Producer-Success-Lesson-12-Professional-Image/
Producer Success Lesson 12: Professional Image
Nothing happens until somebody sells something. To make sales happen, IMMS.com Key Sales Consultant Randy Schwantz has created a comprehensive series of 43 Producer Success Lessons. Used singly or in combination, these powerful tools can help your producers build their skills - and grow their sales.
A huge man saw a sign in the window of a bar reading 'Bouncer Needed.' He walked in and asked, 'You hirin' bouncers? I'm the best - as professional as they come.'
The bartender said, 'What makes you so professional?'
The man replied, 'I can spot trouble from a mile away - watch this.' He walked over to a loud, obnoxious drunk at the end of the bar, lifted him, and threw him out the back door. He came back to the bar with a satisfied smile on his face.
'So, you can see,' he said, 'I know how to do this stuff. What else do I need to do?'
'Talk to the owner,' the bartender answered.
'Great, where can I find the owner?'
'He's coming in the back door right about now.'
Have you ever been so caught up in presenting what you thought was the correct image that you made a silly mistake like this? Many people who regard themselves as professionals have a view of professional behavior that doesn't fit their style - so they either behave in a way that to them is unprofessional but comfortable, or they meet their own standard of professional behavior but they're uncomfortable. Neither scenario contributes to top performance.
What is a Professional?
One description of a professional is someone with extensive specialized knowledge and high standards of client confidentiality, such as a lawyer, doctor, or banker. They often surround themselves with layers of 'professional image' intended to impress others.
What do you really want from such professionals? Not their fancy office or their degrees from Harvard - you want their specialized knowledge to be used to solve your problems. So what a professional is really someone with the extensive specialized knowledge and communication skills to help solve clients' problems.
People Buy from People They Trust
Notice that this definition doesn't mention expensive offices and Harvard degrees on the wall. I also didn't include trappings such as three-piece suits, Rolex watches, and snooty attitudes. These bits of veneer are fine, and you may want to use them to your advantage. But people put on the veneer to impress clients, and what clients care about is expert knowledge.
Did you ever go to a doctor with whom you immediately felt comfortable? It was probably because the doctor was friendly, asked you questions, and listened. Now think about a doctor you didn't like. Was it because they were stuffy and 'professional?'
Instead of imitating someone you've seen and heard about, try being yourself.
Are you unprofessional in some way? Go back to the definition. Would being sincere and open build trust? Of course it would. In fact, taking someone else as a role model will almost certainly inhibit you, causing a breakdown in your ability to communicate and actually reducing trust in the relationship you're trying to build.
The true professional is not someone with a pinstriped suit and highfalutin talk. True professionals are those who know their business, know their clients, and deliver what they promise when they promise. True professionals can be trusted because they are trustworthy, not because they act 'professional.'
The Criteria for Professionalism
We've established that trust is the key ingredient in a professional relationship. What can you do regularly to ensure that that bond of trust will remain in place? Here are some ways:
Know the insurance business
Know your clients (MVPs, Commercial producers, Risk Managers, executives)
Solve problems
Deliver results
Knowing your business means knowing all aspects of it. You should be able to discuss almost any product or program. You should know all your markets, how to fill out forms, and what coverages are available. Stay on top of what your competitors are doing. Read constantly. According to one efficiency expert, reading about your area of interest for one hour every day will give you these results:
In one year, you'll be recognized in your company as an expert.
In two years, you'll be well-known throughout your industry as an expert.
In three years, you'll be a nationally recognized expert in your field.
If you really love the insurance business, reading about it is entertainment, not a chore! You're in a much better position to help your clients when you're the expert.
Knowing your client means really understanding what makes them tick. Ask questions, and really listen to the answers. Spend time getting to know their insurance needs so you can make the best recommendations possible. The more time you spend listening to their problems, the better able to offer solutions you'll be. That's really all we have to build value in the insurance business - effective use of time. One of the most effective uses of your time is getting to know your clients' real needs and desires as they relate to your business.
Solving problems is different from selling products. Some sales training courses euphemistically refer to hard-core selling as problem solving, but that just ain't so. When you're manipulating and pressuring clients, you're not solving their problems - you're creating more for them. Don't be fooled into believing your clients and prospects don't know what they need. They know. Getting them to tell you is the challenge. The only way to uncover that real problem and then offer the ideal solution is to question, question, question. Only when you really understand the client's pain can you offer the right medicine.
Speaking of medicine, there's no reason your solution has to be an extremely technical, hard-to-understand prescription. Stay away from jargon and technospeak when presenting your solution. Clients don't care about that - they care about results.
Delivering results means being on time, on budget, and on top of it. You must do what you say you'll do every time. Failure in this area even once can ruin a relationship. This goes for little things, such as returning phone calls, as well as bigger things, such as presenting proposals on time. Everything you do either moves the client closer to their goal or hinders their progress. Do you insist on results - every time?
Take This Personally
The true professional is able to move from a business relationship to a more personal relationship without a hitch. That's because there isn't supposed to be a wall between the two types of relationships. Business is personal. So feel free to be yourself, and devote the energy you were putting into your 'professional image' to listening to your clients and getting the results they want.
Exercises
List courses that will increase your insurance knowledge. Plan to attend them in the next few months.
Mentally play back your last five interviews. For each one, focus on three areas: rapport building, questioning, and listening. Rate yourself from 1 (low) to 4 (high) in each area. During the interviews, did you ever feel so intimidated that you relied on your technical knowledge rather than your communication skills? Commit to improving in each area.
...
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/2427/Join-Forces-With-A-Life-Professional/
Join Forces With A Life Professional
Harlan Warthen provides a simple, field proven, cost-effective program that you can use to produce a consistent flow of highly qualified Life and financial services leads, as well as a significant number of cross-line sales.
The concept of a P/C agency working with a Life professional isn’t new. However, up to this point, these relationships have seldom produced a steady and consistent flow of leads because no one ever decided who would do what and when. With all of the best intentions, the partnership becomes hit-and-miss at best, and never produces a consistent flow of leads.
THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY: THINGS CHANGE
The insurance industry has undergone a dramatic change. Clients today are completely different from those we dealt with just a few years ago; they’re well informed and can access an unprecedented level of insurance resources through the Internet. The ways in which insurance products are solicited and purchased have also seen dramatic change. Phone solicitation is almost non-existent, thanks to “No Call Lists.” Each year the number of insurance products purchased over the Internet increases.
Although buyers of insurance products and services are still there, the sales strategies that we once used are no longer effective. Industry studies indicate that 15% of all households will purchase some form of Life and financial service within the next 12 months. If you use the Rule of 72, 100% of all insurance purchasing households will purchase Life or a financial service product in the next seven years from someone. It’s no longer a question of “if” — but “when”! Another study by the IIABA found that 70% of households polled were not aware of all of the products and services that their primary P/C agent offered. The study also pointed out that if the client knew what was offered they would have considered purchasing them from the agent.
You have to ask yourself what’s gone wrong — and the answer is plenty! It doesn’t make any difference whether you’re a P/C agent or a Life agent or; it’s harder to do business for a lot of reasons.
Clients are buying insurance and financial services from somebody. P/C agencies have these clients, but lack a process to solicit them effectively — while Life professionals need qualified clients. In this situation, joining forces makes sense for everybody concerned.
THE ROLE OF A PROFESSIONAL ADVISOR
Our industry continues to become more complex and requires a level of knowledge that might be impossible to attain. If your client asks for advice on Life insurance or financial services, you face a dilemma. Can you realistically assume the role of an advisor? Personally, I don’t think you can. The level of additional knowledge, training, and licensing required to make a recommendation in an area outside of your expertise can be staggering. To fulfill the role of an advisor, you must be able to recommend a professional advisor, either within your agency or from an outside source.
When polled, clients say they would prefer to do business with a single insurance professional for advice and answers. Clients don’t necessarily need their primary agent to be able to provide the service or product, but they want to be referred to someone who can. Unfortunately, insurance has become so specialized that neither P/C agent nor the Life agent can provide accurate advice for the other discipline. We can no longer be all things to all people; and even if we could, the level of knowledge and licensing requirements make it virtually impossible. The P/C agents and the Life/financial services professional need each other. To provide clients with access to a full array of insurance products and services, you need to create a strategic alliance with a Life professional based on trust and professionalism.
TYPES OF ALLIANCES
These alliances come in two forms:
An External Alliance between your agency and a Life General Agency or an Independent Life Agency.
An Internal Alliance between your agency and a Life Specialist.
Each of these types will work, as long as there’s agreement between the parties up front. In essence, the agreement determines who has responsibility for individual tasks and when those tasks will be performed. The choice is which type of alliance would be the most beneficial to you and the interests of your clients. Here’s an example of each type:
EXTERNAL ALLIANCE
A Life General Agency or an Independent Life Agency alliance with a P/C agency is essentially the same; both would be considered external alliances. The major difference is the size of the organization. The Life General Agency has a tendency to be the larger of the two. In most cases, they would have access to significantly more resources, several layers of management supervision, and many more agents. Independent Life Agencies operate the same as Life General Agencies, but usually on a smaller scale; they don’t necessarily have one primary Life insurance company, but broker policies to a number of companies.
INTERNAL ALLIANCE
An internal alliance involves your agency hiring an experienced in-house Life specialist who has access to Life and financial service products through your agency’s existing Life company appointments. This specialist should have an above average level of Life and financial services experience and hold at least their Series 6 and 63 licenses, as well as an advanced designation (CLU, ChFC, etc.)
A MATTER OF TRUST
Building a strong alliance between your agency and a Life specialist must be based on trust. You need to trust the specialist not to jeopardize your existing clients by “hard sell” tactics; the specialist must trust you to provide qualified leads. This mutual trust requires both parties to understand the benefits that each will enjoy.
MAKING THE ALLIANCE WORK
As was mentioned earlier, there’s nothing new about Life specialist arrangements with a P/C agency. Everything starts out great, with each party sending business to the other. If forming such partnerships makes so much sense, why have most of them failed? First, no one puts together a plan or process for developing referred leads on a regular and consistent basis. Second, no one determines who’s accountable for what and when. Finally, and most important, the P/C agency doesn’t perceive that the Life specialist brings any added value to the relationship.
Make no mistake: Making your alliance with a Life specialist work will require time and patience. Although the relationship might be difficult at times, both parties will enjoy a dramatic long-term payback.
HOW THE ALLIANCE WORKS
This strategy is built around a “Client Coverage Survey” that will identify what products and services the client is interested in. Your agency doesn’t have to implement a new marketing plan because the survey is completed at the end of every client service request. The Client Coverage Survey will produce leads in a volume that you’ll have a hard time believing: Although results will vary, this sales strategy can produce three or more applications per week.
BUILDING A WORKABLE AGREEMENT
To build a successful, mutually beneficial alliance, you’ll need to
Do your homework to select the right partner
Analyze the client base
Create a written Alliance Agreement that will deal with:
Compensation
The accountabilities and responsibilities of each participant
Housing the Life specialist
Covering additional operating expenses
Other factors to consider include your agency’s: (1) premium volume; (2) Number of policyholders/ households; (3) percentage of Personal Lines and Commercial Lines business; (4) renewal ratios; and (5) resources.
MAKING A COMMITMENT
Last, but far from least, all participants must commit to making the alliance work. As so often in life, your commitment will determine whether you’ll succeed or fail. I guarantee that you’ll succeed if you commit to implementing the process as it was designed. If you want to change it down the road, be my guest — but keep in mind that my system works the way it was written. Consider doing it my way first before you decide to reinvent the wheel.
EXPECTATIONS
Make no mistake: an alliance with an in-house Life specialist will work to everyone’s advantage. The potential results from a well-structured alliance are enormous A Life specialist can expect to produce consistently 75 to 150 new Life applications per year. In addition to new Life revenue, your agency can expect 10% to 30% in additional cross-line sales, as well as improved retention — all with a minimum amount of effort.
Establishing a strategic alliance between your agency and a Life specialist is a WIN/WIN situation for all concerned.
...
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/201/Professional-Designations-For-CSRs/
Professional Designations For CSR's
Education is often termed a 'ticket to success'-and with good reason! More and more career-conscious agents and their office-support personnel are attending professional development programs.
Since 1987, nearly 18,000 people have enrolled in these three major industry education programs:
Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR)
Certified Professional Service Representative (CPSR)
Accredited Customer Service Representative (ACSR)
People who participate in such programs gain practical knowledge that gives them an edge on the job and improves their professional image.
The programs are offered through a series of one-day courses in major cities across the country. The training varies in format, testing, and prerequisites, but all require continued education once the designation is earned. The specifics of each program are outlined below, along with a phone number to call for more information.
CISR
This program consists of five one-day courses covering personal residential property, Personal Auto exposures, Commercial Property coverage, Commercial Casualty insurance, and agency operations. Participants must pass all five exams to earn the designation. The program has been offered by the Society of Certified Insurance Service Representatives since 1987. Call (512) 346-7358.
CPSR
Coordinated by National Association of Professional Insurance Agents (PIA), the program features nine one-day modules in three areas: Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, and agency-operation skills. Participants select from three learning tracks, tailoring the training to their job responsibilities. To be awarded the CPSR designation, individuals must have at least two years' agency/industry experience and pass the exams in at least six of the modules. The program is offered through PIA state and regional associations. Call: (703) 836-9340.
ACSR
This program includes nine day-long modules, with the option of Personal Lines certification (five courses), Commercial Lines certification (six courses), or certification in both areas (all courses). Developed by Independent Insurance Agents of America (IIAA), the program covers technical, account-selling, and professional skills. Candidates are tested by the state association upon completion of the courses for the desired certification. Call: (703) 683-4422.
If you haven't pursued any of these professional development opportunities, consider what they can do for you and your professional image. Talk to your superiors about the possibility of attending.
CSR FORUM's can contribute to your knowledge base, too! In fact, participants in THE CSR program may soon have the opportunity to earn continuing education credits. Stay tuned for more details....
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/1737/THE-AGENCY-MISSION-STATEMENT/
The Agency Mission Statement
THE AGENCY MISSION STATEMENT An agency mission statement is a simple outline of the agency's overall goal. It should be phrased in terms of meeting the needs of current and potential clients, and should indicate your business emphasis. The mission statement can address the type of service you want to offer and the clients you wish to attract, and/or it can outline your agency goals in a general manner. If you address the client and prospective client, since you can then also use your mission statement in advertising and brochures. Here's an example of a client-driven mission statement: 'It is the mission of XXX Agency to provide professional services and programs to our clients in keeping with our published service standards. Our service standards are given to all clients and represent our written commitment to those high standards. The written commitment is backed up by our staff of professionals, who are being exposed to training and developmental programs on an ongoing basis.' There are many different versions of mission statements. Whatever is used should highlight positive agency features and make some form of commitment. Here are samples of mission statements from a few successful firms: STAEBLER MISSION STATEMENT To achieve security and prosperity for our clients and ourselves through ongoing, rewarding and supportive relationships, by providing insurance and financial services. COMPANY POLICY We will achieve the Mission Statement: With highly qualified, sincere, caring and motivated staff and By continually assessing and improving our service and products ANCHOR PACIFIC GROUP MISSION To be the vanguard of innovation by combining an array of Life, Health, voluntary employee benefits, Property/Casualty, and Workers' Compensation plans into creative, dynamic and cost-effective programs-designed, marketed, underwritten, and serviced by a single source. TRISSEL GRAHAM & TOOLE, INC. DAVENPORT, IOWA MISSION STATEMENT Our mission is to continue to be the most successful independent insurance agency in the Quad Cities. Our objective is to NEVER lose an account as a result of poor service. We recognize the inevitability of occasionally losing an account to price, for we cannot control the pricing of our competitors. We can and will control the service we provide to our clients. If we attempt to place ourselves in our client's position and try to treat the client as we would like to be treated, we will succeed. ULRICH VOORHEES WARNER ASSOCIATES OUR MISSION To provide superior insurance, risk management, and related services for a selective clientele. We will be recognized by our clients and suppliers as a highly respected, innovative, and professional sales organization that maintains excellence in all areas of interaction. We will foster a corporate culture that stimulates, recognizes, and rewards employees for achieving and exceeding individual and corporate goals. THE LIEBERT GROUP STATEMENT OF MISSION Our mission is to be the best insurance agency in the New York metropolitan area. As a sales organization, we are committed to growth and longevity. This will be achieved by obtaining the highest level of profits, by providing our customers with the best insurance protection for their individual needs. We will maintain the highest level of honesty and professionalism in dealing with our customers on an individual basis. We will reserve a high sensitivity to their needs. We will actively solicit new clients that fall under our underwriting standards and sales objectives. We will service our existing clients as if each is our most important account. We will maintain the highest level of honesty and professionalism in dealing with our companies through our marketing, underwriting, claims handling, and accounting. We will strive toward open communication with our underwriters and their managers. We will treat all employees as our most important asset by providing equal employment opportunities, creating a learning and challenging environment and encouraging ongoing education to allow all employees the opportunity to grow within our company. We are committed to full automation within our agency and complete interfacing with our companies. We will strive to maintain leadership in our community by supporting our... local organizations. GHA We are an employee-owned sales and service organization providing cost-effective Property & Casualty insurance, risk management, and financial services. OUR MISSION: To fulfill the changing needs of current and prospective clients, while striving for the highest level of professional excellence in our products and services. To provide an atmosphere of teamwork and employee participation with opportunity for professional growth, personal satisfaction and financial security. To build and maintain long-lasting, consistent and profitable partnerships with insurance markets. To enhance shareholder value by increasing our client base, dedicating ourselves to increased productivity and profitability consistent with long-term earnings-per-share growth. We will accomplish our mission with leadership that will ensure perpetuation of our corporate culture. We will adhere to rigid moral and ethical standards in all our dealings, as we meet the challenges of the future. We are confident in our ability to create and maintain a GHA Team that is the very best at what we do. SPARKS INSURANCE, INC. Welcome to Sparks Insurance, Inc. We are a company that works together as a TEAM. We will: 1) Strive to develop individual and office professionalism. 2) Set and achieve sales and growth goals. 3) Create, establish, and perform efficient work habits and methods. 4) Strive for a unified and pleasant working environment. And last but not least: 5) After accomplishing all of the above, the Sparks Insurance team should become more profitable, and we will endeavor to pass a portion of these profits on to the team members. MISSION STATEMENT: Sparks Insurance, Inc. is a full-service insurance agency committed to providing the best in coverage and service for its customers at a competitive price. We will secure all types of insurance coverage using risk management techniques for both Personal and Commercial lines customers. We will provide a pleasant work environment with opportunities for education, personal enrichment, and career advancement. We expect our employees to be professional, ethical, motivated, and concerned for the client and the agency. We will be a profitable, growth-oriented agency. We will have an annual goal of at least 15% growth in revenues without sacrificing service to our existing clients or profitability to our companies. We will offer our services in those geographic areas where we can achieve the previous mentioned commitments. ROSS & YERGER'S GOAL To be the ultimate firm in the insurance profession, regarded as second to none in serving the interest of our clients MISSION STATEMENT Ross & Yerger is committed to... providing our clientele the highest-quality insurance and services that address risk management, bonding, employee benefits, and financial planning needs. serving the needs of individuals and businesses that are financially stable and seek long-term relationships. attracting and retaining employees with absolute integrity who are intelligent, dedicated, motivated, and committed to the highest standards of professionalism. providing the necessary training, support and motivation so each employee develops his or her maximum potential, including attaining the appropriate professional designation. serving others by encouraging involvement in civic, charitable, educational, and political affairs. maintaining profitability to ensure the continuity and perpetuation of the firm. Saginaw Underwriters, Saginaw Financial Planners, Inc. & SURCO MISSION STATEMENT The mission of Saginaw Underwriters, Saginaw Financial Planners, Inc. and SURCO is to provide professional insurance, financial, and real estate services to the Greater Saginaw area; To help each of our employees develop to their maximum potential so they may feel completely fulfilled personally as well as a part of the Saginaw Underwriters team; Furthermore, for Saginaw Underwriters to operate in the most efficient method possible, to earn a reasonable profit for the company and retain enough earnings so that the company can grow and prosper in the future; Each employee is encouraged to spend a reasonable amount of their time in community service to help our community be a better place in which to live. HORTON INSURANCE AGENCY, INC. MISSION STATEMENT FOR THE 90s To become a strong, regional, full-service agency by maintaining an aggressive sales posture; adhering to the highest standards of excellence; and providing a broad range of products to fiscally sound industries regarding their business and personal insurance needs. Our desire is to communicate a passion for service to our community, our companies, our customers, and our staff. We want our firm to be the epitome of professionalism, teamwork, integrity, and conservative business practices. We believe that our people are the key to the success of our organization. We feel a great sense of responsibility to continue a sound growth pattern that will enable each of our employees to achieve at their maximum level. We are committed to rewarding our employees by providing educational opportunities, benefits that protect them both now and in the future, and an environment that encourages growth as people, as well as employees. In summary, we believe that we have a sacred trust to protect our customers, encourage the growth of our employees, and achieve a reasonable profit. Our success will be measured against these principles. PERSONAL LINES OTTAWA MISSION STATEMENT Our clientele is our life line. We are here to serve them professionally with integrity. We must continually improve on product knowledge to remain competitive. Our goal is to write new business; however, a bigger goal and one that really proves our competence is retaining business. With this in mind, a good attitude must be developed to serve our clients and convey their requirements to the insurers. STRATEGY 1) Prospecting will be increased from [YEAR] on single-line accounts. Also, Murray has and is calling all good cancelled files to see if we can re-quote. This will generate leads in [NEXT YEAR]. 2) We will use brochure drop-offs where appropriate. 3) Chris is working with one property management company to prospect tenants' policies. Results will be monitored. 4) We will continue to encourage Commercial producers to write Personal Lines. Murray will continue to attend Commercial Lines meetings. 5) [NEXT YEAR] risk counts will be followed closely to determine growth. We anticipate these to be accurate this year. 6) Compu Quote is to be installed February [NEXT YEAR]. This will assist prospecting and free up Personal Lines producers to write more business. 7) Advertising in the Ottawa Carleton teachers bulletin has commenced. Results will be reviewed for analysis. Same for advertising done in Century 21 bulletin. COMMERCIAL LINES OTTAWA MISSION STATEMENT We want to be a department that provides professional and innovative attention to our customers. We want our clients to consider us an important part of their business. We want to create and nurture an environment that is harmonious, supportive, and friendly. We want to work to ensure the ongoing prosperity and growth of our company, as well as that of our insurers, so that we too may prosper. STRATEGY 1) Continue use of sales centre to develop leads. 2) Continue IMMS tapes to help generate sales ideas. 3) Establish an exclusive jeweler block program with Gore (first quarter). 4) Establish a farm equipment program in January [NEXT YEAR] through Gullivers. 5) Analyze company results and review companies we wish to support. 6) Continue to encourage Personal producers to write Commercial Lines. 7) Continue IIS as a source of income. RHODES & WILLIAMS LIMITED (Toronto) MISSION STATEMENT Rhodes & Williams Limited's mission is to be the very best at helping people and companies protect all their assets. To be a well-recognized insurance brokerage in the province of Ontario for offering professional advice and management of insurance services. To be a well-recognized and profitable insurance brokerage. STRATEGY 1) Continue to account sell. 2) Use more Yellow Pages advertising. 3) Improve service to our existing book to maintain clientele. 4) Continue to offer Life or Group to all Commercial accounts. 5) Review availability of purchasing a small producer if one became available. 6) Continue to watch expenses closely for savings needed to be profitable. BHJ, Inc. We Believe:'BHJ, Inc. is a group of professional people specializing in the sale of insurance and real estate with a common goal of profitability earned through sound and ethical business practice, while benefiting the community, our employees, and their families.' POTTS, DAVIS & CO. POTTS, DAVIS & CO is the leading independent insurance agency in the mid-Willamette Valley. We are committed to the professional sale of quality insurance services, focusing our efforts in Salem, Portland, and the surrounding areas. We are dedicated to growth and profitability for the continued security of our clients and employees. Policy Statements WE WILL conduct ourselves with honesty and integrity. WE WILL recommend and provide coverages that meet the protection needs of our clients. WE WILL represent quality markets on behalf of our clients. WE WILL provide opportunities for the professional growth of our employees. WE WILL treat people with courtesy and respect. WE WILL place coverages that provide insurers an opportunity for profit. WE WILL total-account sell. WE WILL provide complete, accurate submissions to our carriers. WE WILL support the growth and development of our community by encouraging employee involvement. WE WILL seek and represent clients whose business provides us an opportunity for profit. WE WILL follow and enforce our agency credit policy. WE WILL maintain an environment that encourages the highest and best use of each employee's individual strengths and skills for the overall corporate good.
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/2162/DIVORCE-AND-AGENCY-VALUE-SEPARATING-GOODWILL/
Divorce And Agency Value: Separating Goodwill
DIVORCE AND AGENCY VALUE: SEPARATING GOODWILL by Roy Phillips In my agency valuation work with agents and their spouses in divorce cases over the past 15 years, the issue of professional goodwill has often arisen. When a couple divorces, they seek to divide their community interest between them. All assets and liabilities must be assessed to enable the court to make an equitable division of property. If one of the spouses is an insurance agent, his or her book of business thus becomes subject to valuation, and such intangible property often depends a great deal on professional goodwill. In my opinion, there are two types of goodwill in every insurance agency. The first is intrinsic goodwill. Simply stated, this is the continuation of the client base even after the owner has departed because of death, disability, or retirement. It takes into account the ability of the agency to retain clients through very little effort of the owner. Elements of this goodwill include the service of tenured staff, insurance companies (including their products and prices), location, history of the agency in the community, and other factors. These elements are not based factors that are separate from the clients' dependence on the agents' expertise, reputation, contacts, and special relationships. A doctor's clinic serves as a good analogy. If a sole-practitioner physician dies, becomes disabled, or retires, intrinsic and professional goodwill both come to an end. If another physician acquires the practice, the clinic might retain some patients from the previous doctor. These patients retain the new doctor because of past good experiences, friendly nurse and staff, location, and the clinic's long history in the community. This is intrinsic goodwill. The new doctor, if experienced, may bring professional goodwill of his or her own. That is, the new doctor may keep some patients and attract new ones with skill and personal qualities. In divorce cases involving a professional person, Texas courts have tended not to grant the spouse an interest in professional goodwill. In one case, the court held that the goodwill of a professional person may be as much an asset to be sold as that of a merchant. The professional person is seen to have individual goodwill that can't be detached from his or her person, and thus can't become a part of the community property. Take the landmark case Rathmell v. Rathmell, for instance. In 1975, agent John Rathmell, and his non-agent spouse divorced. After a settlement, which divided the agency's value between the parties, the spouse appealed, alleging that disclosure of the agency's value had been improper. Attorneys filed a Bill of Review asking the Court of Appeals to correct the inequity. Although a number of issues were involved, the Court of Appeals made an important decision concerning the division of professional goodwill. It determined that the sale and service of insurance accounts, which primarily exist in an intangible form, was based on the professional goodwill of the individual agent. What's more, the agent had the opportunity to compete for the business without the prohibitive contractual considerations that might exist in an employment contract. The court essentially decided that the trial court had erred in not assessing this type of goodwill and attributing such value to the agent. The Court found that the appellant, the insurance agent John Rathmell, had developed professional goodwill even though he was not a lawyer or a doctor. It went on to state that the value of the Rathmell companies should have excluded the value attributable to the time, toil, and talent Rathmell expended after the divorce and/or his willingness not to compete with the agency. (It's important to note that Rathmell served without an employment contract, and was not obligated to refrain from competing for the corporation's business. In addition, there was no buy-sell agreement that established the valuation method to be employed in transfer of the firm.) In this case and others, the court established a doctrine of non-divisibility of professional goodwill. It's obvious that this issue has many facets. For instance, sometimes both spouses work in the agency, and have achieved a loyal following through their individual and collective goodwill. Another landmark case in Texas arose from the divorce proceedings of a physician (Nail v. Nail). The court held that the 'accrued goodwill of his medical practice did not constitute property subject of the division upon divorce as part of the estate of the husband and wife.' The opinion continued, 'Professional goodwill has the following attributes: It attaches to the person of the professional man or woman as a result of confidence in his or her skill or ability. It does not possess value as an asset separate and apart from the professional's person or from his individual ability to practice his profession. It would extinguish in the event of the professional's death, retirement, or disability.' Frequently, I'm the only consultant making the appraisal. This is common, as it is in mediation action directed by the court. This can save significant amounts of time, money, and (maybe most important) grief. It's also important to add that both parties often disagree on their own vested interest in this issue of professional goodwill. As a result, there has been a movement to change the law. A spouse contended to the Court of Appeals that the Nail v. Nail case law was wrongfully decided. The Court of Appeals basically responded, 'Appeal it to the Texas Supreme Court, and let them grant a writ of error and change the law.' The Supremes refused to do so. In December 1993, the Texas Supreme Court denied a writ of error in Guzman v. Guzman, and let the issue of non-divisibility stand. They concluded, 'Two Texas Courts of Appeals have recognized that a professional person practicing with others under a corporate structure or as a partnership may have accrued personal professional goodwill, and that there might exist at the same time goodwill attributable to the business or partnership-but goodwill that exists separate and apart from a professional's personal skills, abilities, and reputation is divisible under divorce.' Where does this leave a consultant attempting to determine an agency's value? The court has made it clear that if the aforementioned conditions exist, the personal professional goodwill must be allocated a value. If not, the findings of value are offensive to Texas law. Let's use an example. An agency is a corporate entity, and the agent is the firm's sole shareholder. The contending spouse has been active in the firm to a minor extent in primarily clerical work, but not to the extent of having created personal professional relationships with insureds or markets. The agent and spouse begin the divorce process, which requires evaluation of the business to determine the community interest to be divided. The value components to be considered in determining the agent's professional goodwill might include: the number of major accounts produced by the professional the revenue of such accounts in relation to the agency's gross commission revenues the tenure of such accounts in the agency the accounts' tenure with the carrier insuring them the loss history of such accounts the accounts' payment history the personal relationships that the agent enjoys with the decision-makers in the insured firms Questions affecting professional goodwill might include: Did the agent originate the agency? How much personal supervision does the agent provide on major accounts? Does the agent have significant relationships with the major carriers providing products and services to the agency? Does the agent have important contacts with community members (participation in clubs, networks, and social or civic organizations), which provide exposure that leads to business relationships for the agency? Does the agent have a covenant not to compete in the event that he or she leaves the firm? These are not the only considerations to be investigated by the evaluation consultant, but in my opinion, they're the benchmarks from which to determine that elusive value: personal professional goodwill. Roy L. Phillips, CIC, CPIA, can be reached at Dan R. King & Associates, 4888 Loop Central Drive, #100A, Houston, TX 77081, (713) 667-03...
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/2149/DOING-YOUR-DUTY-PROFESSIONAL-CONDUCT-E-O-AND-YOU/
Doing Your Duty: Prof
essional Conduct,
E&O, And You
DOING YOUR DUTY: PROF
ESSIONAL CONDUCT,
E&O, AND YOU by Roy Phillips and Rick Old
en
ett
el
Ev
ery ag
ent, and
ev
ery ag
ency, has sp
ecific l
egal duti
es to its insur
eds and insur
ers. Th
e U.S. judicial syst
em has always shown th
e fl
exibility of a contortionist. In th
e 1960s and 1970s, it app
ear
ed to tol
erat
e litigation. How
ev
er, sinc
e th
e 1980s, th
e syst
em has mad
e a turn to th
e right. B
ecaus
e som
e stat
e l
egislatur
es ar
e frustrat
ed by f
ed
eral court int
erpr
etations contradicting th
e wish
es of th
eir constitu
ents, th
ey hav
e b
een working to r
ev
ers
e th
e dir
ection of th
e judicial syst
em. M
eanwhil
e, Congr
ess sits on th
e sid
elin
es struggling to impl
em
ent its own ag
enda for tort r
eform. But r
egardl
ess of th
e obstacl
es individual jurisdictions hav
e s
et to bar th
e r
ecov
ery of damag
es, your ag
ency has a duty to m
eet c
ertain prof
essional standards of car
e. With this fact in mind, h
er
e ar
e som
e obs
ervations about what constitut
es such conduct, how failur
e to m
eet th
e standards can l
ead to
errors and omissions (
E&O) claims, and what you can do to pr
ev
ent such claims. As you r
ead this articl
e, k
eep in mind that
each jurisdiction has its own id
eas about what is corr
ect or incorr
ect ag
ency conduct. Your first duty is to und
erstand th
e nuanc
es of th
e applicabl
e court d
ecisions in your stat
e. If you think that sounds lik
e a disclaim
er, you’r
e right. Duti
es to Insur
eds In most jurisdictions, to
establish a caus
e of action for n
eglig
enc
e against an insuranc
e ag
ent, a plaintiff must show that: A duty was ow
ed to th
e plaintiff-insur
ed. Th
e d
ef
endant-ag
ent br
each
ed that duty. Th
e br
each was th
e proximat
e caus
e of damag
es. What duti
es do ag
ents ow
e th
eir custom
ers? On
e court d
efin
ed th
em this way: “An ag
ent ow
es his cli
ents th
e gr
eat
est possibl
e duty. H
e is th
e on
e th
e insur
ed looks to and r
eli
es upon. . . . Th
e insur
ed looks to th
e ag
ent h
e d
eals with to g
et th
e cov
erag
e h
e s
eeks, with a sound company that can and will promptly pay claims wh
en th
ey ar
e du
e. It is his duty to k
eep his cli
ents fully inform
ed so that th
ey can r
emain . . . insur
ed at all tim
es.” This d
efinition calls on ag
ents to prob
e for and id
entify th
eir insur
eds’ n
eeds and conc
erns. Aft
er
examining many
E&O actions, w
e’v
e found that many ag
ents hav
e fall
en on th
eir own swords simply by sup
erimposing th
eir id
eas, n
eeds, and conc
erns upon th
e voic
el
ess insur
ed. In fulfilling th
eir r
esponsibility, b
e sur
e to docum
ent th
e r
esults of n
eeds-analysis conv
ersations. A good axiom: If som
ething is important to th
e insur
ed, it d
es
erv
es to b
e explor
ed and docum
ent
ed in d
etail. An ag
ent also has a duty to us
e r
easonabl
e dilig
enc
e in placing th
e r
equ
est
ed insuranc
e and to inform th
e cli
ent promptly if unabl
e to do so. In addition, an ag
ent has a duty to notify insur
eds of th
e expiration of th
eir polici
es (
exc
ept for dir
ect-bill
ed r
en
ewals) and to pass on any information p
ertaining to
expiration dat
es that’s int
end
ed for th
eir custom
ers. Practically sp
eaking, an ag
ent has a duty to r
en
ew a custom
er’s policy, r
eplac
e th
e policy with on
e from anoth
er company, or notify th
e custom
er of a non-r
en
ewal so th
e custom
er can obtain insuranc
e els
ewh
er
e. It’s important to r
em
emb
er that
each jurisdiction has tim
e fram
es for giving notic
e of non-r
en
ewal. Many of th
es
e r
equir
em
ents ar
e stat
ed in mandatory
endors
em
ents to various policy forms us
ed in
each stat
e. Ag
ents also hav
e a duty to inv
estigat
e th
e solv
ency of an insuranc
e company with which th
ey plac
e a cli
ent. On
e l
egal d
ecision h
eld that, in th
e ev
ent of an insur
er’s insolv
ency, an ag
ent is not liabl
e for an insur
ed’s unpaid claim as long as th
e insur
er was solv
ent wh
en th
e policy was procur
ed. How
ev
er, th
e ag
ent could still b
e h
eld liabl
e if, at a lat
er tim
e, wh
en th
e insur
ed could still b
e prot
ect
ed, th
e ag
ent l
earn
ed — or by
ex
ercising of r
easonabl
e dilig
enc
e should hav
e l
earn
ed — of facts that would put a r
easonabl
e ag
ent on notic
e that th
e insur
er pr
es
ent
ed an unr
easonabl
e risk. Many jurisdictions hav
e statut
es that impos
e a high
er d
egr
ee of car
e on th
e plac
em
ent of an insur
ed’s cov
erag
e with non-admitt
ed carri
ers. Som
e statut
es also plac
e a duty upon th
e ag
ent to s
eek admitt
ed carri
ers for th
e plac
em
ent first and, if unsucc
essful, to advis
e th
e insur
ed of plac
em
ent with a non-admitt
ed insur
er. Ag
ents also hav
e duti
es arising from stat
e lic
ensing r
equir
em
ents. Th
e statut
es
explicitly stat
e what th
ey r
equir
e of ag
ency p
ersonn
el involv
ed in insuranc
e acquisition. Th
e lic
ens
e d
efinition of an ag
ent cl
early stat
es that anyon
e involv
ed in acquiring insuranc
e must b
e t
est
ed and th
en lic
ens
ed. Aft
er b
eing lic
ensing, and in tand
em with th
e lic
ens
e cod
e, all lic
ens
ed p
ersonn
el must m
eet th
e stat
e’s r
equir
em
ents for continuing
education. Som
e stat
es hav
e “grandfath
er
ed” ag
ents who r
ec
eiv
ed th
eir lic
ens
es b
efor
e a c
ertain dat
e. How
ev
er, in our opinion,
ex
empting anyon
e from r
egular continuing
education pos
es a dang
er to an ag
ency. Som
eon
e in your ag
ency, pr
ef
erably a principal, should ov
ers
ee th
e continuing
education of
each
employ
ee. Th
e mom
ent you sign an application to b
ecom
e a lic
ens
ed insuranc
e ag
ent, you assum
e a duty to p
erform s
ervic
es to any and all futur
e insur
eds. Among oth
er things, this m
eans that you hav
e an impli
ed duty to: B
ecom
e prof
essionally awar
e of your products and mak
e ev
ery
effort to communicat
e that knowl
edg
e to
ev
ery individual in your organization; Apply that knowl
edg
e to
each cli
ent’s r
equir
em
ents, which you’v
e gath
er
ed by r
es
earching th
e cli
ent’s busin
ess and p
ersonal activiti
es; S
eek th
e appropriat
e product(s) to fill thos
e n
eeds; Communicat
e th
e availability and oth
er p
ertin
ent issu
es for
each product pr
es
ent
ed, using writt
en and oral communications that would b
e ordinarily und
erstandabl
e to th
e cli
ent; Insist on acknowl
edgm
ent wh
en
ev
er th
e cli
ent r
ej
ects your opinions conc
erning
exposur
es that you think r
equir
e tr
eatm
ent; Prop
erly apply for, r
ec
eiv
e, r
evi
ew, and transmit s
el
ect
ed polici
es to th
e cli
ent,
ensuring continuity through all four actions; Docum
ent th
e actions in st
eps on
e through six, and b
e pr
epar
ed to
ensur
e that chang
es ar
e mad
e in a tim
ely mann
er on b
ehalf of th
e cli
ent.; and B
e pr
epar
ed to show that you hav
e establish
ed int
ernal ag
ency proc
edur
es that indicat
e a “r
easonabl
e int
ent” to control actions tak
en und
er st
eps on
e through s
ev
en. W
e b
eli
ev
e that th
es
e abbr
eviat
ed st
eps ar
e among th
e important
el
em
ents that mak
e up an ag
ent’s “duty to p
erform.” W
e’v
e arriv
ed at this opinion aft
er r
evi
ewing doz
ens of cas
es
ev
ery y
ear. Duti
es to Insur
ers Ag
ents also hav
e duti
es to th
eir insur
ers. On
e authority d
efin
ed this duty in th
es
e t
erms: “An ag
ent ow
es th
e insuranc
e company h
e r
epr
es
ents a fiduciary duty that includ
es loyalty and good faith, int
egrity of th
e strict
est kind, fair, hon
est d
ealing, and th
e duty to not conc
eal matt
ers which might influ
enc
e his action to pr
ejudic
e th
e company.” In addition, th
e ag
ent ow
es th
e insuranc
e company th
e duty to comply with its guid
elin
es, polici
es, and proc
edur
es for issuing polici
es. Many courts hav
e h
eld that any p
erson who solicits an application for insuranc
e shall b
e r
egard
ed, in any controv
ersy b
etw
een an insur
ed and th
e company, as th
e ag
ent of th
e company, not as an ag
ent of th
e insur
ed. D
espit
e b
eing an ag
ent of an insur
er, an ag
ent do
es not hav
e th
e pow
er to waiv
e, chang
e or alt
er any of th
e t
erms or conditions of an insur
er’s application or policy. Caus
es of
E&O Claims L
et’s consid
er a f
ew
exampl
es of how br
eaching th
es
e duti
es can l
ead to
E&O all
egations. Our cli
ents in th
es
e cas
es ar
e usually th
e ag
ents (d
ef
endants), although w
e hav
e r
epr
es
ent
ed insur
eds and carri
ers in doz
ens of cas
es ov
er th
e last 10 y
ears. Our job is to wad
e through th
e volum
es of pl
eadings, d
epositions,
exhibits, int
errogatori
es, and caus
es of action that such cas
es g
en
erat
e to find answ
ers to four qu
estions: Did th
e ag
ent fail to satisfy a l
egally impos
ed duty to p
erform on b
ehalf of th
e insur
ed (or insur
er)? Did th
e ag
ent r
epr
es
ent th
e goods and s
ervic
es h
e or sh
e provid
ed to hav
e charact
eristics, us
es, or b
en
efits th
ey did not hav
e? Did th
e ag
ent fail to disclos
e information about a policy to induc
e an insur
ed to purchas
e it? Had such information b
een disclos
ed, would th
e insur
ed hav
e r
ej
ect
ed th
e policy? Did th
e ag
ent
engag
e in any unconscionabl
e conduct? H
er
e ar
e a f
ew cas
es from our fil
es that d
emonstrat
e common br
each
es of ag
ents’ duti
es. On
e of th
e most pr
eval
ent is failur
e to obtain prop
er cov
erag
e, as th
es
e two cas
es show. Cas
e 1: Th
e insur
ed had ask
ed th
e ag
ent to find appropriat
e cov
erag
e for his fur-cl
eaning firm. Unfortunat
ely, th
e ag
ent did not obtain insuranc
e cov
ering th
e bail
ee exposur
e that com
es with cl
eaning and storing valuabl
e fur it
ems. R
esult: Finding for th
e plaintiff (th
e insur
ed). Cas
e 2: Th
e insur
ed, a swimming pool subcontractor, r
equir
ed G
en
eral Liability and oth
er cov
erag
es to maintain his busin
ess r
elationships with his cli
ents (g
en
eral contractors). A C
ertificat
e of Insuranc
e was issu
ed to a g
en
eral contractor indicating that th
e insur
ed had all th
e cov
erag
es r
equir
ed by th
e g
en
eral contractor’s contract. Th
e g
en
eral contractor r
eport
ed a loss arising from th
e insur
ed’s work. Th
e loss r
esult
ed in discontinuation of und
erground utility s
ervic
e to a major manufacturing plant. Th
e insur
ed did not hav
e appropriat
e cov
erag
e for th
e und
erground prop
erty damag
es. Th
e g
en
eral contractor’s insuranc
e carri
er r
espond
ed to th
e loss, and th
en subrogat
ed against th
e insur
ed. Th
e insur
ed th
en su
ed th
e ag
ent. R
esult: Finding for th
e plaintiff (th
e insur
ed). Failur
e to obtain prop
er cov
erag
e accounts for mor
e than 50% of all loss
es r
eport
ed to
E&O carri
ers. A similar, but slightly diff
er
ent,
error is th
e failur
e to obtain r
equ
est
ed cov
erag
e, which accounts for 20% of such claims. H
er
e ar
e a coupl
e of
exampl
es: Cas
e 3: Th
e insur
ed instruct
ed his ag
ent to r
evi
ew his insuranc
e and d
et
ermin
e wh
eth
er h
e was ad
equat
ely cov
er
ed for th
e cons
equ
enc
es of having to mov
e his pr
emis
es aft
er a prop
erty-insuranc
e loss. (Do
esn’t this sound a bit lik
e Tim
e-
El
em
ent cov
erag
e?) A loss occurr
ed, but Tim
e-
El
em
ent cov
erag
e had not b
een purchas
ed, so
extra-
exp
ens
e moni
es w
er
e not in plac
e to hir
e th
e mov
er, l
eas
e th
e n
ew location, put in th
e phon
es, bring in n
ew inv
entory, and notify th
e insur
ed’s custom
ers of th
e chang
e. G
etting back in action rapidly was crucial for th
e insur
ed’s busin
ess of s
elling upscal
e formal gowns to high-school s
eniors who w
er
e graduating within th
e n
ext f
ew w
eeks. R
esult: Finding for th
e plaintiff (th
e insur
ed). Cas
e 4: Th
e insur
ed ask
ed th
e ag
ent to obtain cov
erag
e that would pay first-dollar claims to his cli
ents in th
e ev
ent that th
eir prop
erty was damag
ed through th
eft or vandalism. H
e was willing to pay for th
e additional cov
erag
e sinc
e h
e was in th
e busin
ess of s
ervicing M
erc
ed
es-B
enz
es, Rolls Royc
es, Jaguars, BMWs, and oth
er
exp
ensiv
e cars. Vandalism occurr
ed on
e w
eek
end, and th
e insur
ed was forc
ed to sp
end thousands of dollars r
epairing 11 v
ehicl
es l
eft in his car
e. Primary Garag
ek
eep
ers Liability insuranc
e was not in plac
e to r
espond to th
e claim, but you can gu
ess what was: th
e ag
ent’s
E&O policy, of cours
e! R
esult: Finding for th
e plaintiff (th
e insur
ed). Th
es
e four cas
es d
emonstrat
e th
e n
eed for continuing
education. All of th
es
e E&O loss
es could hav
e b
een pr
ev
ent
ed if ag
ency p
ersonn
el had b
een train
ed to r
ecogniz
e th
e sourc
es of cli
ents’ pot
ential claims and know th
e products availabl
e to cov
er th
em. Th
e final two caus
es of
E&O claims addr
ess
ed in this r
eport ar
e failur
e to bind cov
erag
e and failur
e to obtain r
en
ewal cov
erag
e. Whil
e th
es
e r
epr
es
ent only 10% of claims r
eport
ed, th
ey d
emonstrat
e th
e n
eed for
establishing standard op
erating proc
edur
es within an ag
ency. A Syst
em Is th
e Solution Wh
en
errors or omissions occur in an ag
ency, it’s oft
en b
ecaus
e employ
ees don’t p
erform tasks th
e sam
e way
each tim
e. To achi
ev
e uniformity, your ag
ency must hav
e a “syst
em.” Your ag
ency manag
em
ent syst
em coordinat
es s
ev
eral int
err
elat
ed syst
em compon
ents. Sp
ecifically, th
e syst
em provid
es th
es
e s
ervic
e compon
ents: Locat
es pot
ential cli
ents (mark
eting compon
ent) Gath
ers data and analyz
es n
eeds (risk-manag
em
ent compon
ent) Coordinat
es risks with products (cov
erag
e compon
ent) Approach
es th
e mark
etplac
e (plac
em
ent compon
ent) Pr
es
ents findings to th
e cli
ent (proposal compon
ent) Impl
em
ents s
el
ect
ed products (application compon
ent) Arrang
es for paym
ent s
el
ection (accounting compon
ent) Maintains int
erim s
ervic
e (s
ervic
e compon
ent) R
evi
ews chang
es in cli
ent profil
es (r
en
ewal compon
ent) Maintains quality of staff training (training compon
ent) B
ecaus
e th
es
e syst
em compon
ents ar
e int
err
elat
ed, it’s vital to us
e proc
edur
es that pr
es
erv
e th
eir int
egrity. First, it’s important to d
efin
e “automation.” If th
e comput
er databas
e includ
es only accounting information, th
e ag
ency isn’t r
eally automat
ed. R
em
emb
er that accounting is only on
e syst
em compon
ent. Th
e truly automat
ed ag
ency is driv
en by a singl
e databas
e that includ
es all cli
ent information r
equir
ed to p
erform th
e tasks associat
ed with th
e 10 syst
em compon
ents. Onc
e th
e ag
ency manag
em
ent syst
em is in plac
e,
ev
eryon
e in th
e ag
ency must obs
erv
e c
ertain rul
es. If Mos
es had b
een an insuranc
e ag
ent, th
er
e would hav
e b
een thr
ee additional commandm
ents: Thou shalt consist
ently p
erform all proc
edur
es th
e sam
e way
ev
ery tim
e th
ey’r
e carri
ed out. Thou shalt docum
ent all custom
er transactions, id
entifying dat
e, tim
e, r
ecomm
endation or action, r
esultant action, and follow-up; and Thou shalt not allow anyon
e to circumv
ent or d
estroy th
e syst
em. Th
e thr
ee groups of off
end
ers most lik
ely to violat
e th
es
e commandm
ents ar
e th
e ag
ency’s principals, produc
ers, and long-tim
e employ
ees who hav
e an “anti-syst
em” attitud
e. What can b
e don
e about th
em? Bas
ed on th
e th
eory that ag
ency principals think th
ey actually op
erat
e th
eir ag
enci
es, w
e can assum
e that th
e enlight
en
ed on
es will
eith
er s
eek training to b
ecom
e syst
em-lit
erat
e or d
ep
end on som
eon
e who has this training for all transactions. Outsid
e produc
ers gath
er data out of n
ec
essity, but th
e int
egrity of this data isn’t always r
eliabl
e. Th
e solution:
Equip produc
ers with appropriat
e forms that r
efl
ect th
e r
equir
em
ents of th
e syst
em – and l
et th
em know that using oth
er “forms,” such as cocktail napkins, is as br
each of th
e syst
em. As for syst
em-loathing
employ
ees who hav
e b
een with th
e ag
ency sinc
e th
e original tabl
ets cam
e down from th
e mountain, giv
e th
em a cl
ear m
essag
e: Adapt or l
eav
e! To find out if your syst
em is working, audit th
e flow of transactions through th
e 10 ag
ency s
ervic
e compon
ents. Hav
e this audit don
e by an obj
ectiv
e obs
erv
er. In oth
er words, don’t l
et folks audit th
eir own trails, so that th
ey can l
earn th
e str
engths and w
eakn
ess
es of th
eir subordinat
es and id
entify training n
eeds. Th
e audit format should r
efl
ect your ag
ency’s proc
edur
es and obj
ectiv
es. For
exampl
e, if your policy is to off
er umbr
ellas to
each Comm
ercial account, th
e audit should d
et
ermin
e wh
eth
er this policy is b
eing impl
em
ent
ed.
Ess
entially, th
e audit ch
ecklist should mirror th
e task list constituting
each syst
em compon
ent. Your ag
ency’s syst
em can b
e as simpl
e as a not
ebook containing standard op
erating proc
edur
es or as
ext
ensiv
e as your n
eeds dictat
e. Th
e k
ey is to hav
e a syst
em. Innovation, spontan
eity, and cr
eativity hav
e th
eir plac
e in ag
ency manag
em
ent, but not in th
e ar
ena of daily insuranc
e transactions. With so much at stak
e, variation is no virtu
e — which is why parachut
es ar
e pack
ed th
e sam
e way
each tim
e! Roy L. Phillips, CIC, CPIA, can b
e r
each
ed at Dan R. King & Associat
es in Houston, (713) 667-0333,
ext. 227,
e-mail
[email protected], or ...visit www.kingphillips.com. Rick L. Old
en
ett
el is a partn
er at Old
en
ett
el & McCab
e, Attorn
eys at Law, in Houston. Adapt
ed, with p
ermission, from Am
erican Ag
ent & Brok
er magazin
e.
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/1997/GROW-REVENUES-OR-SHRINK-EXPENSES-HOW-TO-IMPROVE-AGENCY-PROFESSIONALISM/
Grow R
ev
enu
es Or Shrink
Exp
ens
es: How To Improv
e Ag
ency Prof
essionalism
GROW R
EV
ENU
ES OR SHRINK
EXP
ENS
ES: HOW TO IMPROV
E AG
ENCY PROF
ESSIONALISM by
Elizab
eth Mill
er Although w
e’v
e s
een many ag
enci
es
enjoy tr
em
endous profits ov
er th
e y
ears,
Elizab
eth Mill
er b
eli
ev
es that th
e pot
ential for growth r
emains v
ery high. With strat
egic acquisitions, strong sal
es
efforts,
effici
ent proc
ess
es, and good
exp
ens
e manag
em
ent, th
er
e’s no r
eason why ag
enci
es can’t continu
e to incr
eas
e th
eir profitability. Most busin
ess prof
essionals und
erstand that th
er
e ar
e only two basic ways of improving profitability: Grow r
ev
enu
es and/or shrink
exp
ens
es. In th
e insuranc
e industry, growing r
ev
enu
es can b
e don
e in s
ev
eral ways (such as acquiring a n
ew ag
ency, incr
easing rat
es and
engaging in good, old-fashion
ed s
elling).
Exp
ens
e savings can com
e about in many ways, from improving th
e effici
enci
es obtain
ed through automation to adjusting th
e comp
ensation packag
es for diff
er
ent
employ
ees. R
EV
ENU
E GROWTH Acquisition activity has r
emain
ed a major growth strat
egy in th
e industry. During th
e past f
ew y
ears, about 13% of ag
enci
es hav
e acquir
ed anoth
er ag
ency. How
ev
er, th
e siz
e of th
e acquisitions has shrunk. On av
erag
e, th
e growth in r
ev
enu
e obtain
ed from acquisitions w
ent from $525,000 in 2000, to $550,000 a y
ear lat
er, p
eak
ed at $833,000 in 2002, and th
en dropp
ed off significantly to slightly mor
e than $500,000 in 2003. Although th
e industry is still using acquisitions as a growth strat
egy, th
e fact that av
erag
e r
ev
enu
es from acquisitions ar
e down substantially m
eans that profits won’t grow as quickly as r
ev
enu
es. This is b
ecaus
e th
e av
erag
e organization tak
es about
eight months to consolidat
e op
erations from n
ewly acquir
ed subsidiari
es, r
egardl
ess of th
e siz
e of th
e acquisition. B
ecaus
e th
e tim
e to consolidat
e r
emains constant, small
er acquisitions tak
e long
er to r
ealiz
e profitability. W
e might b
e hitting a lull in acquisitions, as th
e inv
entory of s
ell
ers is shrinking. R
ec
ent tr
ends show that larg
er firms rank
ed ag
ency or book acquisitions s
econd or third in futur
e growth strat
egi
es, whil
e produc
er r
ecruitm
ent cl
early r
emains th
e l
eading strat
egy.
Ex
ecutiv
es in many industri
es op
erat
e und
er th
e assumption that bigg
er is b
ett
er and oft
en go to gr
eat l
engths to show growth. I’d advis
e th
em, “Don’t grow for th
e sak
e of growing. A larg
er top lin
e do
esn’t always incr
eas
e profits.” In th
e Ind
ep
end
ent Ag
ency Syst
em, cli
ent sal
es grow th
e top lin
e, but mor
e importantly,
effici
ency will grow th
e bottom lin
e. Wh
en s
ervicing your cli
ent bas
e, it’s important to und
erstand th
e cli
ent’s industry and cr
eat
e workflows that will maximiz
e automation, whil
e s
erving th
e cli
ent with as f
ew st
eps as possibl
e. Ag
ents oft
en fail to und
erstand th
e idiosyncrasi
es of c
ertain industri
es. As you
ent
er n
ew mark
ets, b
e awar
e of diff
er
ent s
ervic
e issu
es, and plan accordingly. Insuranc
e ag
ents and brok
ers act as int
erm
ediari
es b
etw
een insuranc
e carri
ers and consum
ers in providing risk prot
ection. Th
e busin
ess partn
ers on both
ends of th
e insuranc
e transaction can mak
e chang
es that th
e ag
ent and brok
er must d
eal with. Som
e carri
er chang
es might r
evolv
e around th
e risk app
etit
e bas
ed on loss tr
ends. Th
e consum
er’s n
eeds might chang
e as th
eir busin
ess
evolv
es. As a s
ervic
e provid
er, ag
ents and brok
ers n
eed to look at th
eir books on a r
egular basis and b
e r
eady to sh
ed unprofitabl
e busin
ess. Wh
en r
evi
ewing your book, first look at th
e av
erag
e n
et r
ev
enu
es that a cli
ent sal
e g
en
erat
es, and th
en
examin
e th
e work r
equir
ed to s
ervic
e this typ
e of cli
ent. Hop
efully, you’ll b
e pl
easantly surpris
ed. If not, ask yours
elf why you’r
e writing this class of busin
ess. B
e awar
e of th
e entir
e cli
ent r
elationship whil
e you ass
ess th
e profitability of writing for a c
ertain mark
et. If you’r
e s
ervicing a cli
ent as an accommodation for oth
er busin
ess opportuniti
es, r
evi
ew th
e profitability of th
e entir
e cli
ent r
elationship, not just a singl
e product. Profitabl
e r
ev
enu
e growth should b
e th
e main focus of ag
ent and brok
er activiti
es. Look to cr
eat
e a workforc
e that’s driv
en by profit, not just sal
es. D
efin
e, communicat
e, and monitor your organization’s goals and obj
ectiv
es cl
early. If you hav
e a small boutiqu
e ag
ency, you n
eed to support sal
es and s
ervic
e efforts that fall within a w
ell-d
efin
ed scop
e of busin
ess. If th
e ag
ency is cr
eating a n
ew nich
e as a growth strat
egy, you must
educat
e produc
ers on this lin
e and cr
eat
e comp
ensation plans that will motivat
e produc
ers to s
ell it. Ov
er tim
e, complac
ency might s
et in. Many produc
ers r
each a point at which th
eir r
en
ewal book h
elps th
em sustain a comfortabl
e lif
estyl
e, without th
e effort of trying to grow th
eir book. Your comp
ensation packag
es should continually motivat
e produc
ers to incr
eas
e th
eir sal
es. Cr
eat
e a “pay-for-p
erformanc
e” atmosph
er
e, whil
e maintaining a strong support t
eam for produc
ers. Mak
e th
e t
eam r
esponsibl
e for r
et
ention, allowing produc
ers mor
e tim
e to s
ell. P/C produc
ers in small
er ag
enci
es t
end to b
e jacks-of-all-trad
es and sp
end mor
e tim
e s
ervicing th
eir
existing book than soliciting n
ew busin
ess. This also holds tru
e of v
ery larg
e ag
enci
es, which look at produc
ers mor
e as risk manag
ers than sal
esp
eopl
e. Th
eir cli
ent sal
es calls t
end to involv
e mor
e consultation than s
elling. M
edium-siz
e firms g
en
erally hav
e th
e most aggr
essiv
e sal
es forc
e, in which produc
ers hav
e historically focus
ed
equally on s
ervicing
existing cli
ents and soliciting n
ew busin
ess. SHRINKING
EXP
ENS
ES
Exp
ens
e savings com
e in two forms: tangibl
e (m
easurabl
e) and intangibl
e (unquantifiabl
e). Tangibl
e exp
ens
e savings can b
e as basic as r
en
egotiating your offic
e suppli
es or as compl
ex as r
eallocating spac
e to accommodat
e mor
e work in a small
er ar
ea. Intangibl
e savings ar
e usually mor
e compl
ex and g
en
erally involv
e how work is proc
ess
ed. Don’t b
elittl
e chang
es that you can’t quantify. Mor
e effici
ent op
erations that might not b
e m
easurabl
e can improv
e your productivity significantly. Ag
ents and brok
ers m
easur
e productivity by commission r
ev
enu
e p
er
employ
ee. This figur
e should av
erag
e b
etw
een $100,000 and $150,000 — and
ev
en high
er in larg
e firms. Although th
e Ind
ep
end
ent Ag
ency Syst
em has adopt
ed a vari
ety of automation tools during th
e past f
ew y
ears that should’v
e improv
ed productivity significantly, productivity gr
ew only about 3% from 2002 to 2003. This is about half th
e 6% annual productivity gain r
ealiz
ed b
etw
een 2000 and 2002. Som
e s
ectors of th
e ag
ent-brok
er industry
ev
en witn
ess
ed a d
ecr
eas
e in productivity. D
espit
e th
e robust capabiliti
es of ag
ency manag
em
ent syst
ems, many ag
ents and brok
ers hav
en’t r
ealiz
ed productivity gains b
ecaus
e employ
ees,
esp
ecially produc
ers, hav
e r
esist
ed automation. Sinc
e produc
ers ar
e usually th
e starting point of any n
ew busin
ess transaction (“nothing happ
ens until som
ebody s
ells som
ething”), it’s
ess
ential for th
em to
embrac
e th
e automation solutions availabl
e. Until produc
ers agr
ee to us
e th
e ag
ency manag
em
ent syst
em, it will b
e difficult to impl
em
ent automation fully. Int
egration of acquisitions can chall
eng
e many buy
ers. Aft
er a purchas
e clos
es, obstacl
es to tackl
e includ
e: (1) consolidating op
erations; (2) bl
ending th
e cultur
es of th
e two organizations; and (3) clarifying and communicating th
e chain of command. Although consolidation is usually th
e easi
est to achi
ev
e and will yi
eld th
e larg
est boost to th
e bottom lin
e, many organizations try to bl
end th
e cultur
es and
establish r
eporting r
elationships b
efor
e th
ey consolidat
e. This approach do
esn’t work as w
ell. Wh
en making an acquisition, b
e pr
epar
ed to mak
e th
e tough d
ecisions — or don’t do th
e d
eal. P
eopl
e ar
e not only your most valuabl
e ass
et, th
ey’r
e your larg
est
exp
ens
e. You n
eed to mak
e good choic
es, announc
e th
em quickly, and th
en g
et on with th
e r
est of th
e proc
ess. Y
es, th
e consolidation of op
erations will usually yi
eld an ov
erall r
eduction of workforc
e,
esp
ecially in th
e administrativ
e ar
eas — and that’s tough to fac
e. But d
ecr
easing ov
erh
ead salari
es will incr
eas
e profit margins. And isn’t incr
eas
ed profits on
e of th
e r
easons you mad
e th
e acquisition in th
e first plac
e? Today, w
e’r
e in th
e midst of a soft mark
et. As pr
emium hik
es slow, it will b
ecom
e mor
e important to boost your bottom lin
e by shrinking
exp
ens
es. Ag
enci
es that r
einv
est
ed th
eir high profits g
en
erat
ed during th
e hard mark
et in p
eopl
e and t
echnology will b
e b
est position
ed to produc
e profitabl
e growth in th
e n
ear futur
e.
Elizab
eth Mill
er is a vic
e pr
esid
ent with Busin
ess Manag
em
ent Group (BMG), a consulting firm that has b
een h
elping ind
ep
end
ent ag
ents and brok
ers for mor
e than 20 y
ears. To l
earn how BMG can assist you, visit www.bmgconsulting.com, call toll fr
ee at (800) 772-0208, or contact th
e author dir
ectly
emill
e[email protected]. R
eproduc
ed, with p
ermission, from Prof
essional Ag
ent magazin
e. ...
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/472/Online-Education-For-Risk-And-Insurance-Professionals/
Online Education For Risk And Insurance Professionals
According to a Wall Street Journal article, there’s been a dramatic increase in the number of executives returning to classrooms to 'brush up on traditional management skills and to learn new ones.' In the risk management and insurance industries, this is nothing new. Whether it’s a required continuing-education course, or a CPCU class, risk and insurance professionals have always pursued higher education.
For years, classroom courses that prepare students for national exams have been available throughout the nation. Some students, though, don’t have the time or the patience to sit through a weekly three-hour course for 18 weeks. That’s why the Institutes, Risk and Insurance Management Society (RIMS), and other organizations have created online exam-preparation courses that offer risk and insurance professionals more educational options than ever before.
RIMS’ ONLINE ASSOCIATE IN RISK MANAGEMENT (ARM) COURSES
I was intrigued when I heard that RIMS was offering online exam-preparation courses for the ARM series. My classroom experience with the ARM 54 course was less than engaging, as I spent the requisite instructional time confined in a small classroom listening to an instructor ramble on about many topics unrelated to risk management.
I passed the national exam for ARM 54, but wanted to self-study for ARM 55 and ARM 56. Knowing my tendency to procrastinate, I looked for a course with structure to help me avoid cramming the night before exams. RIMS’ new online course for ARM 55 was just the ticket. I enrolled online, paid the fee, and within 24 hours had a user name and password to enter the Web site. RIMS’ easily navigated Web site contains all the needed study information. Online courses are divided into four sections:
Schedule: assignment and exam schedules
Media Center: course materials and exams
Discussions: students’ bulletin board forum for posting thoughts and answering instructors’ questions
Profiles: instructor and student profiles
RIMS’ online learning environment is somewhere between the two extremes of traditional classroom learning and self-study. Instead of dominating the learning environment with a lecture, the instructor serves as a facilitator, laying out the coursework weekly and leaving it up to the students to download the material, study, and take the quizzes. Students must be highly motivated.
The success of RIMS’ online learning environment relies on active student participation. When class began, the discussion area was very active. The instructor posed questions and most students followed up with their thoughts. It was interesting to finish an assignment, jump online, and instantly read other students’ solutions. But after a few weeks, the number of postings dropped and the instructor had to send weekly e-mails to solicit participation. I sometimes waited days before receiving a response from the instructor or other students to my postings in the discussion area. My interest in the course began to wane and I visited the Web site less and less.
When it was time for the national exam the online classroom allowed me to go back and review discussions and assignments. I studied the course materials and sent e-mails to the instructor asking for help in certain areas. With his help, and a review of materials on the Web site, I passed the national exam.
Overall, RIMS’ online learning experience served its purpose. Students who take online courses must remember that it’s up to them to stay current with the assignments and discussions. Aside from the ARM series, RIMS offers other courses, including Fellow in Risk Management test-preparation courses, general risk courses such as Managing Business Risk and Small Business Risk Management, and skill-enhancement courses which focus on improving basic business skills.
CPCU ONLINE SERIES
The American Institute for CPCU recently teamed up with Blackboard.com, an online learning provider, to create an e-learning environment that’s very similar to RIMS’ online educational program. They divide the 'classroom' into three main sections that lead students through their daily activities: announcements, calendar, and tasks.
Claire Reiss, director of the Grants and Research Program at the Public Entity Research Institute, recently completed the online course for CPCU 8-Accounting and Finance, possibly one of the most difficult CPCU courses. As a working mother of two, Reiss appreciated that the course helped prepare her for the exam in a way that fit her schedule. Instead of sacrificing one night per week for a classroom course, Reiss studied online whenever and as often as she liked from her home.
The best part of the course for Reiss was having someone to turn to with questions: 'The teacher was very helpful and responsive. She provided thoughtful responses to our answers to assigned questions, quizzes, and the practice final. She also provided lecture notes that highlighted the main points of each assignment and gave us some advice about how to focus our efforts.' Overall, Reiss enjoyed the course and says it adequately prepared her for the national exam, which she passed.
THE FUTURE OF ONLINE EDUCATION
Claire Reiss and I had similar experiences and outcomes in our online learning adventures. Both RIMS and CPCU provided ways to study on our own time and at our own pace; yet we both noticed that the interactivity of the programs was virtually nonexistent. The format has potential for discussion among students, but lacks the urgency and leadership of a traditional classroom environment that promotes expression of ideas.
Creating the feel of a traditional learning environment online is nearly impossible because it requires more bandwidth (very rapid connections) than most people currently have to deliver the audio, video, and animation required for an interactive educational experience.
Nevertheless, one online education company appears to be ahead of the curve. Corpedia, a Phoenix-based e-learning company specializing in Web based business management and compliance education, uses streaming audio and creative animation to teach courses. I recently completed a one-hour course titled 'Recognizing and Preventing Employment Discrimination,' a look at the laws, history, causes, and other issues surrounding employment discrimination. I was thoroughly impressed with the course’s in-depth content and streamlined visual presentation.
Corpedia presents the material with audio and visual cues that make it interesting and easy to follow. Exams test your knowledge throughout the course. The learning experience is somewhere between watching a training video and sitting through a live presentation. Students can rewind, fast-forward, or pause the lesson at any time. In addition, users can completely stop the course and return later. The course remembers where you left off. The programs also have some nice features for managers who require employees to take the courses. The employer can monitor each employee’s performance and progress, and keep online records of who took which courses.
Although Corpedia’s class catalog focuses mostly on general business management training, many of the topics apply to risk management professionals, particularly such sections as safety, health, legal compliance, and workplace issues.
CONCLUSION
Online learning is in its infancy and far from replicating the interactive experience of traditional classrooms. Nevertheless, students taking online courses benefit from the ability to study anywhere at anytime. As with traditional classroom environments, students must be highly motivated to learn the material, stay abreast of the latest assignments, and join in discussion groups to reap the full benefits of learning online....
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/2620/From-Mom-and-Pop-to-Professional-Shop-Breaking-Through/
From 'Mom-and-Pop' to Professional Shop: Breaking Through
It used to be the $1 million ceiling. That was the level of revenue at which an individual performing agent with a few helpers had to become a business with different people handling different clients and responsibilities. Everyone still worked for the agent, but the agent no longer made every decision.
However, running an agency as a business doesn't automatically result in growth and a high quality of professional service. By the time the agency reaches $2 million, it runs into another "invisible ceiling."
The $2 million revenue mark around which many agents hover for several years is one in which a change in management must occur in order to break into the next level of growth. Owners who have been jacks of all trades, filling the gaps to ensure that customers are serviced adequately, must convert themselves into managing partners. If owners wouldn't spend $100,000 for a Personal Lines customer service representative, it behooves them to staff the agency properly. Then they can use their time in a way that's appropriate for their skill level and that justifies their compensation.
The key to moving into the next generation of growth is to develop a deeper understanding of the power of management. Management is a productive profession, not a frill that can be trimmed in favor of sales or service. How do you explain the appreciation of fine painting to a blind man? He knows he can live without it and can't understand the fuss about applying some textured paint to a canvas. If he were able to see, he might find out that art adds a dimension to his life that he never knew existed. Most owners of small agencies facing the $2 million ceiling without knowledge of management are like the blind man. The only way they know to grow is to repeat they've done in the past, but since the old familiar methods no longer work, they're at a loss. New ways seem risky.
But they don't have to re-invent the wheel. All they need do is review similar companies that have grown through the $2 million mark and into double-digit growth. They'll find that these companies hire enough of the right people to manage the daily workload. They focus their managers on growth, profitability, productivity, and monitoring and managing others to accomplish more than they could ever do themselves.
It takes fortitude to build businesses from scratch-but leverage is what builds large businesses from small ones. The reason that 93% of all businesses never grow beyond their owners' ability to produce personally is that they refuse to invest in people and learn the arts of delegation and management. They feel that their long experience puts them beyond the learning stage. However, the special 7% use their historical success as a springboard to a different level of success and understand that they'll never cease learning their business. Each subsequent level brings new challenges and responsibilities.
If you're facing the $2 million barrier to further growth, consider taking these steps:
Formulate a strategic and tactical plan and budget. Nothing happens until it's written down.
Relieve your owners and key managers of daily process-driven work. If necessary, hire people to accomplish administrative tasks at lower compensation levels.
Determine the most productive thing that each owner can do to justify his/her compensation and focus on those tasks. Growth, productivity, or profit to twice the owner's compensation level is the minimum. Triple justification is more likely to sponsor profitable growth.
Delegating functions doesn't mean delegating control. Maintain control over day-to-day operations through a reporting system that informs you how much comes in, how much goes out, and how many and how old are the items remaining undone.
Knowledge about your business is not just an important thing, it's everything! "I'm too busy" is a poor excuse. Evolve a Management Information System to tell you about new business, renewal status, and lost business.
These steps are the preliminaries to creating a professional agency as compared to the Mom-and-Pop shops that still dot the landscape. The professional agency knows how to move in the right direction to grow. The Mom-and-Pop shop believes that the fates control its destiny and trust in luck. Which would you prefer?...
https://completemarkets.com/Article/article-post/649/The-Keys-To-The-Kingdom-Sales/
The Keys To The Kingdom: Sales
As with so many inventions, improvements, and business successes, the “keys to the kingdom” in sales offer basic common sense solutions to problems that have grown out of proportion for many agents.
PERSONAL LINES
When independent insurance agents were alone in the marketplace, their mere presence and their professionalism drove customers to their doors. Competent agents were asked to provide insurance by an ever-growing client base. The referral system worked.
State Farm, Allstate, GEICO, USAA, Farmers, and many other captive and direct writing companies broke the hold of the independent agent on new sales by providing adequate (or better) products and service and advertising heavily. Advertising works! Meanwhile, most independent agents’ advertising budget consists of their monthly fees to the Yellow Pages.
Now, Internet insurance providers are working on the customers of both the direct writers and independent agencies by offering to “cut out the middleman” and provide fast quotes, 24-hour service and, presumably, lower rates. This will work with Personal Lines commodity products because we’ve spent years convincing the public that all these policies are alike, without stressing the variables that need the expertise of an insurance professional to identify and help solve customers’ problems. Will customers lose something as they flock to the lower prices of the direct writers and Internet providers? Of course. Will they understand this before the uncovered or mishandled loss? Probably not. And because most insureds don’t have losses, the lack of proper coverage is always a hidden land mine to them. What they don’t know won’t hurt them — for the moment.
Does this mean that the Independent Agency System should capitulate and be grateful for the “stable” customer base (estimated at 50%) that won’t shop unless they have a bad experience with their current agent? Should they become “quote mills” for prospects to test the validity of the direct writer and Internet provider claims? Should they resign themselves to losing a percentage of their customers each year?
Successful Personal Lines independent agencies nationwide have proven that they can stand toe-to-toe with the direct writers and Internet providers — as long as they’re selling “Points of Differentiation” rather than price.
The best of these agencies have taught their Personal Lines staffs a mantra about quoting. Said in many different ways, the point that they stress is always the same:
We provide something that neither the direct writers nor the Internet companies can deliver.
The direct writers have a “one-size fits all” mentality — either you fit into their customer template or they can’t insure you. Some direct writers have even turned that weakness into a strength by offering to tell you which other company to access if they can’t give you the best rate. Of course most of the referrals are of less than perfect prospects. The company looks like a hero by turning away the prospects they would have rejected anyway.
As independent agents, we have different companies with different products and different tiers to permit each customer access to the best product at the most competitive price.
Our customers are human beings, not a series of answers to questions on an application. Yes, we take a commission for tailoring your insurance program to you, as an individual — something that your computer will never do for you. Without an agent’s expertise, you’ll only learn that the cut-rate policy you bought online wasn’t exactly right for you when you have a claim.
Quoting is only done face-to-face when we can meet and find out about your insurance needs. There are plenty of places to call for price alone. Successful agents have determined that they’re far more successful if they achieve a 50% closing rate, and that the closing rate for prospects who come to the agency is often four to five times better than the telephone quotes.
The other common characteristic among the most successful Personal Lines agencies is their upgrading of Personal Lines sales positions. Yes, they dedicate people to Personal Lines sales. In some agencies, the Personal Lines salesperson is also responsible for the advertising and marketing campaigns that attract new customers from: (1) Active referrals from the existing customer base; and (2) aggressive local marketing. In larger agencies, marketing is handled outside the department and the Personal Lines sales force is purely dedicated to “wooing and winning” the prospect. As you can imagine, it takes a positive and outgoing personality whose compensation is directly tied to new business sales to be successful in this position. We’ve seen Personal Lines salespeople earning from $30,000 to $50,000+ on a base salary and incentive basis in urban, suburban, and rural areas. Their success is related directly to two factors: Their ability to learn the “mantra” and sell it to the prospects (make them feel comfortable, special, and impressed to have the professionalism of the agency working for them), and the agency owner’s commitment to the marketing program. If either is insufficient, the effort invariably fails.
This aggressive local marketing is surprisingly successful because most people still feel more comfortable and trusting with someone they can touch when the product that they’re buying is an intangible (i.e. insurance protection). The direct writers and Internet providers are doing good jobs steering customers’ concentration away from this nagging issue. The independent agent’s (your) job is to keep reminding them that they can get everything that these other providers are offering — plus a personal touch.
SMALL COMMERCIAL LINES
Some independent agents still believe that Commercial Lines are more insulated than Personal Lines from attack by the alternative marketers. Yet our own companies are supporting efforts to market niches and associations both directly and through agents. This is only a hop, skip, and jump away from direct-written association programs offering BOP policies through their association’s Web sites at rates far below what’s currently offered.
Small Commercial Lines business is actually in greater danger than Personal Lines. It is, in many ways, a virgin market for the direct writers and Internet providers that Personal Lines was in the 1950s and 1960s. They’re simply seeking the homogeneous groupings that will permit them to mass market the products in the same way they do in Personal Lines.
Small Commercial Lines carry a burden that Personal Lines no longer bears. Most agents still over-handle and over-service Small Commercial Lines to the point that they’re not profitable. I know that this is sacrilege to the agents who believe that service is all they have to sell — but it’s time for a reality check. Every agent who hasn’t concentrated on providing service for Small Commercial Lines business commensurate with the income it generates is losing money in that part of their agency.
That does not mean that you should disregard Small Commercial Lines and leave them to the direct writers and Internet providers (who, by the way, run their Small Commercial Lines at a profit). It means that you have to learn to both sell and to service Small Commercial Lines differently than Large Commercial Lines. By the way, there appears to be no common definition of “small” Commercial Lines; size groupings vary by territory and by agency. Some agencies might consider account premiums less than $10,000 as small. Others might describe accounts less than $5,000 as small, and still others consider accounts less than $25,000 as small. It all depends on where you live and how you sell.
The sales technique that seems to work best in the agencies with growing and profitable Small Commercial Lines is to mimic the direct writers. Individual Small Commercial customers, like Personal Lines customers, are invited into the agency to discuss their account with a new business specialist. These agencies concentrate more on their closing rate than on the new business itself because they know if they can achieve a 50% closing rate, the only question is how to market to drive more prospects in the door.
As with Personal Lines, the mantra is learned and sold to every prospect. If all they’re looking for is a low quote, they probably aren’t going to buy from you, and if they do buy from you this year, they’ll be looking around again next year. If you can establish a relationship and make the small business-owner feel like they have your staff working for them, you will diffuse the urge to shop (as long as you follow through on your promises).
A commitment to sales is the primary characteristic of successful Commercial Lines agencies. They market hard and constantly through professional marketers (not CSRs or producers cold calling and sending letters). They track and gauge the success of every marketing campaign on a monthly basis and change them often to make them more successful. Although you can never outmarket the direct writers on a national level, it’s easy to outmarket them within your local territory.
The other significant difference between successful and unsuccessful Small Commercial Lines agents is their dedication to niche and program marketing. They set objectives each year to develop a new niche that can be marketed through their carriers — who are supporting those efforts enthusiastically.
LARGE COMMERCIAL LINES
The competition for Large Commercial Lines (however you define it) comes from a different direction. The large corporate agencies are concentrating their marketing efforts on the marquee accounts in every territory. The agencies created or bought by the financial institutions are also targeting these accounts. The most successful independent agents in Large Commercial Lines have professional sales management, professional dedicated producers, and constant professional marketing to bring them to the same marquee accounts targeted by their competitors.
The field of play is even for the independent agent who maintains strong, close relationships with its carriers through a professional marketer, and hires and maintains only the kind of producers that the agency owners would be proud to have representing them. The failure of most agents is that they simply do not know how to hire and manage producers. The incentives are insufficient and the owners’ support (management and financial) isn’t strong enough.
This is a realm that should be entered only by agents who have the staying power to do it right. Many agents that try (and fail) repeatedly to break into Large Commercial Lines just don’t have the background or skill to do so and would be better served concentrating on the medium and small commercial marketplace.
SERVICE
The nation’s most successful agents are converting their service staff compensation program to an incentive basis (while still maintaining the integrity of salaries) to reward service departments for retention and book of business growth.
Service managers are professional managers responsible for training, coaching, and counsel, and monitor their staff to assure that service is provided in an excellent (and standard) fashion and that every CSR is not a kingdom unto themselves. Managers are also second levels problem-solvers. Managers should never service books of business themselves.
Successful agencies evolve service standards and strategic plans, to form common service cultures that permit them to manage service relationships in a way that never even tempts customers to shop. These agencies are almost religious in their fervor to:
Do it right.
Do it right the first time.
Tell everyone how good we are.
If we make a mistake, catch it, admit it, and make it right before the customer gets upset.
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
Successful agencies no longer run as “seat of the pants” operations. Whether large or small, these agencies have financial managers and rely on the budgeting process to guide their spending habits.
On a year-by-year basis they allocate a specific percentage of revenues to the key expenses (staffing and marketing) and carefully track the success of their tactical plans before spending outside their budgets.
The key to successful agencies’ financial success is the focus that agency owners place on the operating statements and balance sheets. Not surprisingly, every successful agency knows its operating results and balance sheet liquidity ratios on a monthly basis. The first is the measure of operating success and the latter gauges the health of the agency.
Any agency, large or small, can become successful if the principals have the desire, commitment, and intestinal fortitude to do the right things. Whether those things mean upgrading staff, enhancing management or spending money ahead of results, only those truly committed can succeed.
“Flash-in-the-pan” agents who hook onto an “idea of the month,” pursuing it until they encounter too many roadblocks or identify the next “idea of the month,” would be far better off simply maintaining their book of business (replacing lost business) and earning a living until it comes time to perpetuate.
“Status quo” agents earn good livings and avoid the stress of change.
However, there are a number of agencies headed by “Young Turks” who are seeking the path to success. If they follow the trails already blazed by successful agencies, they too can build successful and profitable organization. The demise of the Independent Agency System has been grossly exaggerated as long as creative agents are willing to change to meet the challenges of the future....