Is It Cheaper to Insure an Old or New Car?

How old's your car? To save money, you may prefer to invest in older model cars. The insurance costs could take away any financial benefit, though, so understand if it's cheaper to insure an old or new car.

Drop Comprehensive Coverage

Older cars depreciate in value. Find your car's value in Kelly Blue Book or Edmunds then check your insurance policy.

If you're paying more for your comprehensive coverage than the car is worth, drop it and save money.

Your Age Matters

If you're a young or senior driver, be prepared to pay higher auto insurance rates because statistically drivers in these age groups have a higher risk of accidents.

On average, middle-age drivers enjoy the lowest insurance rates.

Check Out the Safety Features

The safety features on your vehicle can lower your insurance rates since they reduce the risk of accidents. Older cars without features such as automatic brakes and back-up cameras may be more expensive to insure.

Drive Safely

The way you drive can actually influence your auto insurance rates more than your car's age. Maintain a clean driving record to get the best rates.

Know Other Factors that Determine Insurance Rates

Your car's safety features, your age and your driving record impact your insurance rates. Other factors can affect your policy's costs, too.

  • Marital status
  • Gender (depending on the state in which you live)
  • How often and where you drive the vehicle
  • Claim history

If you work with specialty vehicles or commercial operations, you may need a tailored policy — see Auto Transportation Insurance for transport exposures or Auto Repossession Insurance for Tow and Repossession Companies for repossession operations.

How to Lower Your Rates

You increase your chances of earning low insurance rates when you take several steps.

  1. Don't drive while you're distracted. Pay attention to your surroundings and keep your focus on the road.
  2. Obey traffic laws and follow posted signs.
  3. Choose a higher deductible. By increasing your deductible, you can lower your annual vehicle insurance costs.
  4. Improve your credit score. Many insurance companies use your credit score to decide if you're a lower insurance risk, so improve your score to get lower insurance rates.
  5. Add a vehicle. Instead of purchasing two different insurance policies, add the second driver in your home to your policy and save money.
  6. Bundle different policies. Purchase auto insurance from the company that also insures your home or rented apartment, and you'll get a discount on your car insurance.

While the age of your car does affect your car insurance rates, other factors also determine the amount of insurance premiums you pay.

For more details, talk to your agent. He or she can also suggest additional steps you can take to lower your rates and get the insurance coverage you need.

If your vehicle is part of a manufacturing or fleet operation, consider specialized coverage such as Auto Component Manufacturer Insurance (Stamping Facilities) to address those risks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an older car usually cheaper to insure?

Often yes for liability and collision coverage because the car's value is lower, but particular factors like safety features and theft risk can change the cost.

Should I drop comprehensive coverage on an older car?

Consider dropping it if the annual premium plus deductible exceeds the vehicle's cash value, but weigh the risk of an uninsured loss first.

How does my age affect insurance rates?

Insurers charge higher rates for younger and older drivers because statistics show these groups have higher accident risk; middle-age drivers typically have lower rates.

Do safety features really lower premiums?

Yes; features that reduce the chance or severity of a crash or theft can qualify you for discounts with many insurers.

Need insurance for You, Your Family or Your Business?
We can match you to a qualified, local insurance expert!
Further Reading
Overview Healthy eating often feels more expensive, but investing in better nutrition can reduce long-term health costs and protect your income and life insurance eligibility. Small changes—choosing whole foods, planning meals, and avoiding frequen...
Every organization needs great directors. They provide guidance and secure growth for the company now and into the future. You may already employ your company’s future leaders, so use these tips as you recognize great directors in your company and i...
Overview If you own a second home used for getaways, having the right insurance for that property protects your investment and reduces financial risk from damage, theft, or liability. A policy for a vacation property often mirrors a primary homeowne...
Overview How much coverage you carry on the structure of your house determines whether a loss can be repaired or replaced without a large out-of-pocket bill. Insurers commonly base dwelling limits on replacement cost, not market value, and many po...
Millions of Americans take to the water each year during boating season, traveling coastlines, rivers, lakes and canals. Watercraft range from simple rowboats and jet skis to small motorboats and luxury yachts. The need for insurance protection whe...